Scotch at Dan Murphy's, priced every Thursday. Lagavulin 16 and the ten bottles that define it.
Dan Murphy's · week of 2026-11-05

Tomatin 12YO9 outlines · excitement 0.24 · shelf of 2026-11-05

Tomatin 12YO Single Malt Whisky 700mL. One outline per editorial type: what each would say about this bottle this week. Outlines are placeholders, not published pieces. This bottle also has its own page with its price history and its ten nearest.

Editorial typeSaliencePickedOutline
Article0.45An article on Tomatin 12YO leads with its ticket of $90 against a peer median of $96, 6% under. In its 13-week window that is level with its low (earlier weeks: low $90, high $98). Its review speaks of sweet, fruit and its strongest flavour factor is orchard & cereal.
Compare the pair0.04The engine's nearest neighbour to Tomatin 12YO ($90) is The Deveron 12 Year Old ($91). The Deveron 12 Year Old is $1 dearer; the pair piece asks what the extra buys. The engine's indifference price for The Deveron 12 Year Old against it is $98; the ticket is $7 under.
Divergence take0.07By attributes alone Dewar's 15 Year Old is Tomatin 12YO's 6th nearest bottle; once price is counted the engine puts it 62nd. Tickets: $90 against $80. Its peers' median is $96, so it sits 6% under them.
Hot 21 / Cold 210.07Tomatin 12YO is on neither the Hot 21 nor the Cold 21 this week: $90 against a fair value of $93, 2% under, which ranks 278th hottest of 323 bottles. Its peers' median is $96, so it sits 6% under them.
KB position0Tomatin 12YO is the only Tomatin bottle on the shelf, at $90, so the brand has no price band to hold a position on. It is a 12-year-old Highlands single malt at 43% ABV. Its peers' median is $96, so it sits 6% under them.
Price raid0.58Tomatin 12YO fell from $98 to $90 this week, 8% down. In its 13-week window that is level with its low (earlier weeks: low $90, high $98). Its peers' median is $96, so it sits 6% under them.
Similarity surprise0.12The engine's 15th nearest bottle to Tomatin 12YO, a Highlands single malt, is Bushmills 10 Year Old, a Northern Ireland single malt. Tickets: $90 against $72. 1 of its 20 nearest differ from it in country or style. Its peers' median is $96, so it sits 6% under them.
The whole shelf0.08yesOn the Highlands shelf of 38 bottles Tomatin 12YO is 3rd coldest: $90 against a fair value of $93, 2% under. The shelf's median ticket is $129. Its peers' median is $96, so it sits 6% under them.
Value pick0.55For Tomatin 12YO at $90, the closest cheaper neighbour is Glenmorangie Original 12 Year Old at $74: $16 less, 18% of the ticket. The engine ranks it 10th of the ten nearest. 1 of the ten are cheaper by $5 or more.